2025 Stock Market Predictions

Every year, financial experts make bold market forecasts—but most get it wrong. In 2024, the result was no different, proving once again that market timing is nearly impossible. Instead of chasing headlines, investors should focus on long-term strategies rooted in fundamentals and personal financial goals.

The Truth About Market Predictions: Why Most Experts Get It Wrong

Every year, financial analysts, media pundits, and so-called market gurus make bold predictions about the stock market. Some claim the next great crash is imminent, while others insist that a particular sector or investment strategy is the key to outperforming the market. There were predictions about volatility, interest rates, inflation, artificial intelligence, real estate, and where the S&P 500 index would be at the end of 2024. The reality? Most of these predictions turn out to be dead wrong.

In this article, we’ll break down some of the most egregious market calls from 2024, why they missed the mark, and what investors should actually focus on when building a sound financial strategy.

Off the Mark Again on S&P 500 Targets

Just about every major financial institution will put out end of year targets for the S&P 500, as if they have some special insight that the rest of us don’t have. It’s easy to see how the average investor might fall prey to that kind of rhetoric. After all, if anyone had the resources and intel on what the future might hold, it would be these types of companies, whose market caps are upwards of hundreds of billions of dollars (no exaggeration).

But, while money can buy many things, it cannot buy the ability to know the future. That is evident by how wildly inaccurate these S&P 500 targets are each year, and 2024 was no different. We researched market predictions from 16 large, well-known financial institutions, including Oppenheimer, Wells Fargo, Deutsche Bank, Barclays, Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan, and others, and found that the average market prediction across the group for 2024 was a positive 3.4%. However, the S&P 500 returned approximately 23.3% (before dividends) in 2024, a difference of nearly 20 percentage points!

Some of these institutions, like Wells Fargo, Morgan Stanley, and JPMorgan, predicted a negative year for the S&P 500 in 2024, making them even further off the mark.

But what about some of the other companies? Did anybody get it right in 2024? No. Not one. The closest predictor was Yardeni Research, which initially predicted a gain of approximately 13.2% in 2024, which was still over 10 percentage points off the mark.

Some might ask, “What about other years? Maybe 2024 was different.” But, it was not. When looking at the 15 companies we tracked in 2023, the predictions were 23 percentage points off, on average (even worse than 2024).

Unfortunately, the predictors didn’t stop there, but even went into specifics on their forecasts.

Other Wrong Predictions of 2024

BlackRock predicted stocks and bonds would outperform cash in 2024. That didn’t happen as cash returned 5.32% (US Treasure 1-3M) and bonds came in at 1.3% (Barclays Aggregate Index) for the year.

Morgan Stanley said to diversify away from the Magnificent Seven in 2024 and to invest toward value over growth. They were wrong on both fronts. The Magnificent Seven delivered a stunning 65% return in 2024, easily outperforming the broader market. Growth stocks as a whole beat value stocks 32% to 12%, proving once again that betting against innovation and technological advancement is a risky move.

Jeffrey Buchbinder, Chief Equity Strategist for LPL Financial, warned that the stock market would experience significant turbulence due to the election year. He was wrong. Stock market volatility in 2024 was historically low. The VIX, a common measure of market volatility, averaged just 15.5 for the year, its lowest level since 2019. Despite ongoing political and economic uncertainty, the market remained steady and continued its upward climb.

Volatility will always be a part of investing, but making bold claims about extreme fluctuations is often a tactic used to generate fear. The truth is that while volatility can occur, timing it is nearly impossible.

The Motley Fool’s Mixed Track Record

The Motley Fool made several predictions about the market in 2024, some of which were partially accurate, but most missed the mark. Here’s a look at their key calls:

• The economy will dip into recession – Incorrect
• Bear market returns in 2024 – Incorrect
• Yield inversion will end – Correct
• REITs will thrive – Incorrect
• Core inflation will remain stubbornly high or accelerate – Partially correct
• The AI bubble will begin to burst – Completely incorrect
• Utilities will be a top three sector in 2024 – Incorrect
• Tesla will fall below $100 per share – Wildly incorrect

Tesla actually had a strong year, with its stock price nowhere near the $100 mark. Similarly, real estate investment trusts (REITs) did not thrive, contrary to what some experts predicted.

While making market predictions is part of the financial media landscape, the accuracy rate remains abysmal. Investors who make decisions based on these forecasts risk making costly mistakes.

The Biggest Miss of 2024: Harry Dent’s Doomsday Prediction

One of the most outrageous predictions of 2024 came from Harry Dent, who told Fox News Digital that the market was headed for the biggest crash in history. He claimed the S&P 500 would drop 86%, the Nasdaq would fall 92%, and real estate would collapse to 2012 levels.

None of this happened.

The market remained strong, real estate prices held steady, and crypto did not experience the 96% crash Dent had predicted. Unfortunately, these types of fear-driven claims can lead investors to make poor financial decisions, such as moving all their money to cash and missing out on market growth.

Dent has made similar predictions for decades. However, his overall track record is disastrous.

Many analysts, like Dent, will make the same predictions year after year until they eventually get it right. However, by the time they do, investors who followed their advice may have already missed out on years of gains.

The Reality of Market Predictions

Investors are easily led astray by these predictions and don’t see the several factors that lead to these poor results:

1. Some predictors have ulterior motives: Bold, dramatic predictions attract attention and generate clicks, views, and book sales.
2. Markets are unpredictable: No one can accurately predict what will happen over the next 12 months with consistency.
3. They cherry-pick successes: Analysts who make repeated bad calls only highlight the one or two times they got it right.

A Smarter Approach to Investing

Instead of chasing market predictions, investors should focus on fundamentals and long-term planning. Here’s what really matters:

• Build a diversified portfolio based on your financial goals and risk tolerance.
• Ignore short-term noise and stay invested for the long haul.
• Have a plan for volatility but don’t make rash decisions based on fear.
• Work with a fiduciary financial advisor who prioritizes data-driven strategies over market speculation.

Final Thoughts

Financial experts will continue to make bold claims about the market because it sells. However, as history has shown, most of these predictions fail. Investors who follow the advice of fearmongers risk making costly mistakes that could hurt their long-term financial success.

If you want to build an investment strategy that actually works, focus on your financial plan, not market speculation. If you’re interested in creating a portfolio based on data, sound strategy, and your unique retirement goals, schedule a conversation below.

Let’s invest wisely and retire better—without the noise.

Want more help? Let’s chat.